QS_Stars_Methodology_6
QS_Stars_Methodology_6
Ratings: Methodology
Stars
Contents
About QS Stars 2
QS Stars Badges 4
Categories 5
QS Stars process 6
Learning experience 8
Sustainability 22
Global engagement 34
About QS Stars 01 Audit and guidance: To ensure a seamless audit, your university will be
assigned a dedicated QS analyst. They’ll guide you throughout the process, from
data gathering to reviewing your submissions and validating information from
The QS Stars university rating system was With a Stars rating given in at least nine third parties.
launched in 2009 to assess institutions categories and for the institution’s
beyond rankings. Now, with over 700
institutions evaluated worldwide and
partnerships with local governments, QS
overall performance, QS Stars allows
universities to publicly highlight their
strengths, while recognising and improving
02 Scores and badges: Ratings are earned according to the table on page six,
and points are calculated from the data gathered. You’ll be awarded badges to
showcase your institution’s achievements.
Stars has earned a strong reputation as the on areas of weakness.
leading international ratings provider.
03 Marketing and strategy: Equipped with your QS Stars results, your institution
is ready to propel its marketing and strategic planning. Publish and share your
ratings to boost your global reputation, and use our Marketing Guidebook and
extra support to maximise your impact.
The Overall badge reflects your total Throughout this scoring document you’ll find
QS Stars rating, from 1 Star to 5+ Stars. reference to a scaling down process used to
It’s a mark of your institution’s quality. award points for various indicators.
This process is a calculation based on
Category badges thresholds. The maximum threshold will be
awarded maximum points and the minimum
Take a closer look at your institution’s threshold will be awarded zero points. Any
strengths. QS Stars presents distinct badges score in between will be calculated using an
for each category analysed. These category internal formula.
badges range from 1 Star to 5 Stars,
highlighting your institution’s key strengths
in specific areas. You’ll come across both “QS Stars is teaching us
mandatory and optional categories.
more about how we stand out,
Teaching, Facilities OR Online learning,
Social OR Environmental impact, and in which areas we are
Research OR Academic development, performing well, and where
Global engagement, Employability, Good we have room to grow.”
governance are required for all assessments.
2 Stars 15
Overall Points Prerequisites
3 Stars 20
OUTSTANDING 900+ • 5 Star ratings in all categories and meet all prerequisites
4 Stars 30 (5+ Stars) needed for 5 Stars
• 105 points in the Research category
5 Stars 35
EXCELLENT 700+ • 5% international faculty (or 75% of the regional average)
(5 Stars)
• 5% international students (or 75% of the regional average)
Categories with a maximum of 100 points: Facilities, Online learning, Social impact,
• 70 points in the Facilities or Online learning categories
Environmental impact, Good governance
• 85 points in the Employability category
Rating Minimum points
• 150 academic referees OR 3 citations per faculty member*
1 Star 10
• 105 points in the Teaching category^
2 Stars 25
VERY GOOD 550+ • 1% international students (or 25% of the regional average)
3 Stars 40 (4 Stars) OR 85 points in Global engagement
3 Stars 60
Faculty-student ratio
10% faculty-student ratio (one faculty member per ten students) scaled down to 2% 40
(one faculty member per 50 students)
Retention
90% of students carrying over from first to second year, scaled down to 70% 15
Learning management system
3 points each for the following learning management system (LMS) attributes:
1. Available from anywhere at any 4. Staff trained to work
time (including mobile)
2. Communication and/or
with the LMS
5. Reporting and analytics to
15
collaboration tools embedded track progress
3. At least 90%
programmes using LMS
Learning experience
QS Stars surveys and public national surveys can be accepted, as well as your institution’s own
survey with the proper evidence. Results are based on a minimum 20% response rate OR 1,000
respondents, with points being scaled down for lower response rates. Please speak with a QS
When evaluating your university’s learning experience, we examine two core representative to take part in the QS Stars student satisfaction or alumni surveys.
areas – teaching and the learning environment.
Broad subject area ranking OR Subject ranking All indicators in this category relate specifically to the institution’s
Highest-scoring out of five broad Highest-scoring discipline based on chosen specialist programme
specialist areas based on the most the most recent QS World University
recent QS World University Rankings Rankings by Subject or respected Graduate employment rate
by Subject (Maximum points for alternate global subject rankings 95% scaled down to 70% of graduates employed or started a business within 24 months 10
ranked position 1-50, scaled down to (Maximum points for ranked position 40 of graduation
10 points at position 300) 1-20, scaled down to 10 points at
1. Engineering and Technology position 200) Completion Retention
2. Natural Sciences 95% of students scheduled to OR 95% of students continuing from first
3. Life Sciences and Medicine For a full list of subjects please visit graduate succeed in doing so on time, to second year, scaled down to 75% 5
4. Arts and Humanities www.topuniversities.com/subject- scaled down to 65%
5. Social Sciences and Management rankings/2023
Student satisfaction
Internationally recognised AND/ Nationally recognised 90% student satisfaction with the specialist programme, scaled down to 65%
10
accreditations OR accreditations
5 points for each international and 2 points for each national accreditations relative
10 Faculty-student ratio
to a specific, named degree programme within the specialist subject or broad 20% faculty-student ratio (1 faculty member per 5 students) scaled down to 5% 5
subject area (maximum 10 points) (1 faculty member per 20 students)
Arts facilities
2 points each, with 3 additional points for 6 or more from the list, to a maximum of 15
points; all facilities must be open to students and faculty but do not have to be open to
the public
1. Purpose-built museum 6. Dedicated recording studio OR
2. Purpose-built theatre* music practice rooms
3. Concert hall* 7. Campus radio station, TV studio, 15
4. Dedicated art studios OR TV channel
5. Campus art 8. Cinema*
exhibition programme 9. Outdoor art space
(e.g. sculpture garden)
*Must feature at least five performances in 12 months to be considered
Artistic accolades
25 scaled down to five awards or accolades given in a 12-month period to students,
faculty, departments, or the institution as a whole, for publicly accessible works relating
10
to the arts or local/national culture
Apprenticeships OR Internships
10% scaled down to 5% of total 50% scaled down to 10% of total
Incubator
Presence of a business incubator and 5 points for each of the following:
1. At least 20 places for students scaled down to five
2. At least 40% female entrepreneurs, scaled down to 20%
3. 50% of companies still operating after five years (including those purchased by 20
another bigger company), scaled down to 30%
4. 70% of companies receiving seed funding scaled down to 10% (includes funds both
from university and from private entities/companies, but students’ personal funding
investment is not accepted)
Staff satisfaction
75% staff satisfaction scaled down to 50% 15
Sustainability
Institutional accreditation (quality assurance)
At least one institutional accreditation by a national or regional quality assurance agency 10
The Sustainability indicators measure how well your institution is stepping Publication of governance meeting minutes
up to tackle the world’s biggest environmental, social, and governance At least one publication of governance meeting minutes in the last 12 months
10
(ESG) challenges. This dimension includes Good governance and either
Social impact or Environmental impact as mandatory categories. Diversity, Strategy and risk management
equity and inclusion is an elective category. 5 points each for:
1. Strategic plan 2. Risk management plan or
10
equivalent
22 QS Stars University Ratings: Methodology QS Stars University Ratings: Methodology 23
Social impact OR Environmental impact 100
Student diversity
Education 2 points for presence of each type of students, with a 2 points bonus if 4 out of 5 are
represented (maximum 10 points) :
Environmental sustainability networks 1. 10% of students are from legally 5. 5% other underrepresented
10 points for each international and 5 points for each national network that the university
is a member of (up to a maximum of 10 points)
10 recognised ethnic minority
groups (applies to domestic
groups combined (e.g:
LGBTQIA+, neurodiversity) - the
10
students only) percentage applies to the total
Public education and outreach 2. 5% mature students of these groups, but the student
10 public education or outreach activities scaled down to 0 10 3. 30% first generation learners groups here should be different
4. 8% religious minorities from those listed in items 1-4
Environmental sustainability student organisations
At least one dedicated student organisation focusing on environmental
sustainability issues
5 Student gender ratio
40:60 ratio scaled down to 30:70 for either gender 5
Faculty gender ratio
50% female academic staff, scaled down to 30% 5
Student organisations for underrepresented groups
1 point for each student organisation (maximum 5 points) 5
Strategy on equality, diversity and inclusion
Existence of an Equality, Diversity and Inclusion strategy with both defined goals and 5
a time-defined action plan
Pedagogical innovation
Being awarded an international innovation in teaching award in the past five years 10
Teaching spending out of turnover
50% scaled down to 25% of total spending represents expenses with academic staff 20
(including teaching staff costs)
15
Patent grants
50 scaled down to 0 unique, active patents registered with national or international
patent offices (no limitation of time)
20
Patent applications
300 scaled down to 0 unique patents applications (no limitation of time) 10
Spin-off companies
Five spin-off companies established in the last five years, still operating and less than 10
50% owned by the academic institution
Industrial research
10 distinct university-corporate co-authored publications in Scopus™ in a 10 recent 10
five-year period as per the latest QS World University Rankings analysis
International faculty
25% scaled down to 0% international faculty members
20
International students
20% scaled down to 0% international students
20
International exchange programmes
Long-term exchange programmes OR Short-term exchange programmes
(maximum 30 points) (maximum 10 points)
2% inbound (max. 15 p.) and 2% 2% outbound students against total
outbound (max. 15p.) outbound number of students on an organised 30
students against total number international trip lasting at least two
of students on an international weeks and less than three months
exchange programmes lasting three
months or longer