D.V.Razevig - Lightning Protection PDF
D.V.Razevig - Lightning Protection PDF
conductor, incidents of fire caused by lightning discharges in the zone.'. I n view of the fact that Ixeakdown voltage?~of. air gaps,
lightning contlrlc~orsItwe not rare which, thus. played a harmful specially for distances of tcns of metres, have considerable statistical
role in such cases. scatter, lightning conductorz cnsurc protection of an object only with
a certain degree of probability.
The provision of a reliable electrical connection Lctween all
parts of the lightning conductor is equally i m p o r t a ~ t sincz
, during ((L) Experimeqtal Determination of Protective Zone of Light-
the passage of a current through the place of bad contacts, an inten- ning Conductors
sive arcing, wliich can also causc fire, taltcs place.
Protective zones of lightning conductors are determined by
T h e protective action of lightning conductors is based on the experiments on models. During this, it is assumed that the actual
Fdct that charges, stored on its tip in the leader stage of lightning protective zones of real lightning conductors of different heights are
gccmetrically similar to the zones obtained in the laboratory on
models.
High Voltage Engineering Protection from Direct Lightning Strokes 427
The impulse spark discl~argeis used as a model of lightning. lightning mast. For each location of the electrode, a definiie num-
Its development in long gaps takes place in two stages the leader and ber of discharges is produced. The experiment shows thai for
the main stages. I t is in this way, qualitatively identical lvith t h e
lightning.
The experiments are co~lductedaccording to the experimental
set up of Fig. 31.2 ; the electlaode from which the discharge deve-
lops imitates the end of the leader
canal a t the height of orientation of
lightning. I n experiments conducted
in the Soviet Union by A.A. Akopyan,
for lightning rods of a height upto
30 m, If/h was taken to be equal 10
20, and for ground wires Hlh=lO.
For lightning conductors of height
above 30 m, the height of orientation
=- -- was taken to be constant (H=600 111
~ i 31.2~. D. ~ for the~ ox- ~for lightning
~ ~ masts, and~ H=300~ for Fig. 31.3. Dotorminetion of t h o prot,octivc zono
perimontal dctermi~ationof t h o ground wires). The values taken can- of o, lightning mast on its model.
protective zone ; lVG-Impulm not be rigorously justified, however,
Generator ; l-electrode
imitating the end of t h o leader there is a basis to assume that their R-3.5 h all discharges strike the lightning mast. For Rl sornk-
at the height of use gives somewhat lower protective G t e r than R. a Dart of the discharges strikes the a;.ound.
of lightning ; 2-model of the zones, thus ensuring a definite margin lIuricg this, the discharies deflect very rnucuh away from the verti-
lightning conductor (mast) ; 3- of safetv. cal and strike the ground at a distance r > l.6h. The quantity r
grounded metallic plane.
is the radius of the protective zone at the ground level. The dis-
I n spite of the fact that inost of lightning discharges to earth tance R is called the radius of zone of 100% strokes to the light-
have negative polarity, discharges of positive polarity are used dur- ning mast.
ing an experimental determination of protective zones. This is due The protective zone at a height h, is determined with the help
to the fact that a meeting streamer, as though making the lightning of a mast of height h, which models the object to be protected. T h e
mast longer, develops from its tip during a lightning stroke into electrode and the model of the object which are initially situated i n ,
raised objects. However, the length of this meeting streamer for the same plane, are shifted with respect to each other and in relation
lightning rods of a height upta, 100 metres does not exceed a few to the model of the lightning mast. For each mutual location of the
tens of metres. In those spark gaps with which one has to deal in electrodes a definite number of the discharges is conducted. As a
laboratory, the discharge start:; developing from lightning mast if the result, the maximilm distance r, between the model of the object
polarity of the upper electrode is negative and greatly increased pro- and the lightning mast a t which the model of object is not struck by
tective zones are obtained. With positive polal-ity of the upper the discharge, is found. This distance r, is the radius of protective
electrode the meeting streamer from the lightning rod comprises zone of the model of lightning mast at a height h,.
a small fraction of the spark gap (upto 113) which is much closer to
the conditions occurring during lightning discharges. However, the
necessity of using that polarity which does not occur in natural con-
ditions testifies to very approximate modelling of the real processes
in a laboratory. Therefore .it should be remembered that the pro-
tective zones obtained in a labloratory are of a conditional nature
and we can use them, only because many years of observations of the
performance of real lightning masts conhrmed the reliability of the
gecommendations worked out on the basis of laboratory experiments. If the lightning conductor is not a, lightning mast but a groi~nd
wire, thr electrode and thc ohject are shifted along the horizontal in
The technique of experirncntal determination of the protective a plane perpendicular to thc ground wire (Fig. 31.4). Experience
zones is as follows (Fig. 31-3). Tllc electrode. located at a height shows that in this case the dimension of protective zone is b= l.2h,
H, is shifted in the horizontal direction rclativc to the model of and the dimension of the zone of' 100% stroke to the model ofground
Protection from Direct Lightning Strokes 429
428 High Voltage Engineering wliere IL-height of lightning conductor ;
wire equals B-2h. If the electrode is shifted further, thus increasing rz-radius of the protective zone a t a height h,
the distance upto the vertical plane in which the ground wire is h,-level under examination above the surface of ground
(or height of the object to be protected) ;
h-- ha= h,-projection of height of the lightning conductor above
the level undcr examination (or above height of the
object to be protected) ; called the active height of the
lightning conductor.
In order to be protected from direct lightning strokes, the
object must be fully located within the cone like space whicll
represents the pro:ective zone of the lightning mast.
Since during experimental determination of protective zones,
a number of departures from real conditions are permitted. there is
situatcd, smaller and srnailer strokes will occur to the ground wire
and finally, at a certain distance, all the discharges will occur only to
thc ground T h e distribution of stroke:; determined experimentally is
shown in Fig. 31.5, fi.on1 which i t follows that on an average all
discharges of lightning. developing a t a distance R<3h from the
ground wire occur to the ground wire.
L !a- -+I
I
Fig. 31.9. Protcctivo zone of two I ~ g h t n i n gmast . of dlffcrc ,it h ~ ~ g l ~ t ~ .
Tllc illtcrnal par1 of the protective ;one of two lightning
nlcrsts (Yig. 31.8) in a plane, passing through both the Construction of protective zones for two ligl~tning r n l 5 . c o r
liglltning masts is hounded by the arc of a circle whic11 can be different h e i ~ h t sis shown in Fig. 31.9.
Protection from Direct Lightning Strokes 433
432 High Voltage Engineering The protective zones at a level h , tor tllrec ant1 foilr lightning
masts are shown in Figs. 31-10 and 31.1 1.
At first the protective zone of higher lightning mast is
constructed. After that through the tip of the lightning mast of
smaller height a horizontal line is drawn till it intersects the
protective zone of the single lightning mast of greater height.
Considering that the tip of a certain fictitious lightning mast
coincides with this point of intersection 3, protective zones of' the
lightning masts 2 and 3 of the same height hz and situated at a
distance u', are constructed.
Such objects as the equ~pment of outdoor distribution su1'-
stations are located on sufficiently large territory. They have
I
I
Fig. 31.11. A r m ~t n height h, protected by four lightning
masts which uro l o c ~ t c dn t thc corners of a rectangle.
..---I.-_-- _/I
is essential.
The nlinimun~height of lightning masts 4, 5, 7 and 8 is
I n this
way, it is possible to use the same active height
b kas;7.5 m forall tlfe lightning masts. The objects to be protected
Fig. 31.13. Protoctivc zone of ground wire.
. a maximrlm helght of about 11 m.(busbars of the slrbstation), B
436 High Voltage ~ngineering
3
At a level I&,<- h, half the breadth of the protective zone is :
3
+
'
suspension of conductors (ha)is greater than 213 the height of suspen-
sion of the ground wires (h) ; usu(a1ly hslh is about 0.8. For ound
w a i n s t e a d of the term protectze zones, the t p n protective ang es
is used. Protective angle of a g r o c s r e is the angle between a
, vertical line passing through a ground wire and the line joining a
conductor and the ground wire and lying on the plane perpendicular
to the conductor axis (Fig. 31.1 5). protected in the cl#nab of 13@ years. Besides this, the objects to be
In a single lightning mast of a height 1=30 m situated in a protected are. iarzdbod in the protective zone with a certain margin
r e ( i ( ~ ~of average intensity of lightning activity, direct strokes occur ofsafety, which wry p M t y increase the reliability. Hence for
lightning masts, the necessity of correct determination of the probabi-
lity with which the protective zonesshave been found out, does not
arise.
438' High Voltage Engineering Protection from Direct Lightning Strokes
If the object happens to be a conductor, suspended on a string We ,will find 'the necessary cross-section of the current carrying
a
of insulators which, with its other end, attached to a cross arm, it II parts of lightning conductors, lightning receivers and current carrier.
is necessary to satisfy the condition While calculating the heat developed in these parts, we shall
neglect the heat radiated to the surrounding medium. The energy,
VI1) 150 R+50 E, (30.12) given out during the passage of current through a resistance per unit
where V,,-is the impulse flashover. voltage of the string of insu- length, c2.n be calculated as
lators.
Tn the case when the object and the lightning conductor are
.separated by an air gap of length 13, the condition
v, must be satisfied.
S$ - *
E,,, Since the front of lightning current wave has a small effect on
the heating of the conductor, we shall take
Taking the value of the permissible average intensity of the 0.7
electric field in air gaps E,,,=SOO KV/M we get :
iJl ~,,,e -'IT =Ie FW
-- t
520.3 Rs+O.ll 1, dl. (31.13)