Unit Different Types Of: Objectives
Unit Different Types Of: Objectives
4.1 Introduction
4.4 Tragi-Comedy
4.5 History Plays
4.6 Problem Play
4.7 Realistic Drama
4.8 Poet~cDrania
4.9 Epic Theatre
4.10 Theatre of the Absurd
4.1 I Classical Sanskrit Theatre
4.12 Let Us Sum Up
4.13 Exercises
4.14 Suggested Readings
4.0 OBJECTIVES
The objectives of this unit is to discuss in detail the klnds of drama that we see
being performed or read. Plays are categorised and labelled as tragedy, comedy,
history, problem plays, poetic drama. epic drama, the theatre of the absurd, etc. The
present unit explains as to how these distinctions are made; what reasons behind
the specific labels are; and what time period (socially and politically) has been
responsible for their growth. The unit has a sub-division on Indian Classical Sanskrit
Theatre which discusses the Indian aesthetic theory. One would do well not to
ignore Sanskrit drama as it has been a landmark development in the growth of
theatre at the world level. This also initiates the growth of drama as part of new
literatures which is inclusive of Spanish, German, French, Indian dramatic writing,
4.1 INTRODUCTION
Different types of Drama have existed down the ages from Greek classical theatre
to the present times. We have already read about the origin and growth of drama in
our first unit. Let us answer a few questions about drama which helps us understand
the different kinds of drama entertaining, realistic, romantic, relations-based, theme-
4.2 TRAGEDY
Aristotle first defined tragedy in his Poetic's around 330 BC. He defined tragedy as
"the imitation of an action that is serious and also as having magnitude, complete in
itself," in the medium of poetic language and in the manner of dramatic rather than
of narrative presentation, i~ivolving"incidents arousing pity and fear wherewith to
accon~plishthe cathars~sof such emotion."
Drama: An Introduction Aristotle says that the tragic hero will evoke pity and fear if he is neither thoroughly
good nor thoroughly bad but a mixture of both but is certainly "better than we are in
the sense that he is of higher than ordinary moral worth. Such a man is exhibited as
suffering a change in fortune from happiness to misery because of his mistaken
choice of an action, to which-he is led by his hamartia, the tragic flaw or the error
of judgment or a moral weakness in character. The plot evokes tragic pity and fear.
In this way tragedy relieves the spectators of harmful emotion. The dramatist
depicts incidents which arouse pity and fear for the protagonist, bringing the plot to
a logical and foreseeable conclusion. This explains how an audience experiences
satisfaction even from an unhappy ending. In Shakespeare's King Lear, Lear's
madness and his death arouses pity and fear in the audience, thus catharsis in
spectators gives a satisfaction despite it being a tragic play. "In his tragedies
Shakespeare is indeed grappling with the whole world on a scale approximated only
by the profound tragedians of Greece. Tragedy in his work goes beyond individual
failure, Nations crumble, and ambition, lust and ingratitude sear the earth. Sensitive
souls shudder. They question the chimeras of man and fate, receiving dusty answers.
Love for them turns to mockery, common decency become a jest, they see blood
flowing like a torrent; conscience gnaws at the marrow of their being; self disgust
and a general disgust with mankind ravage many of them" (Gassner:234). Thus
Hamlet and Lear are partially authors of their own suffering because of their
conduct. Hamlet's sharp questioning of man and society emanates from the dramatic
shock of discovering the murder of his father and his mother's infidelity; but later
his procrastination are aberrations from sound policy. Man struggles against man.
Thus it is drama of individual will. Aristotle's definition excludes many plays which
are commonly thought of as tragedies. Not all tragic heroes suffer because of a
tragic error.
Contemporary critics suggest a cluster of overlapping perspectives which collectively
describe the tragic vision.
First, tragedy begins by asking the ultimate questions: why are we here? Does life
have meaning or purpose? Can life have meaning in the face of so much suffering
and evil in the world? Does death negate the significance of the protagonist's life
and the goals helshe was seeking? Tragedy offers no singular solution: people
suffer because of their own actions. At times the tragic hero appears to suffer
simply because helshe lives in a cruel and unjust universe. Though the causes of
suffering are diverse, yet the purpose of suffering appears almost universally
acknowledged: only through suffering does a person attain wisdom. According to
Francis Fergusson, the plays follow a tragic pattern of purpose, passion and
perception.
Second, tragedy pushes the individual to the outer limits of existence where one
must live or die by one's convictions. Facing the end of life, a person quickly
recognizes life's ultimate values. Tragedy depicts men and women who dissatisfied
with the hand destiny has dealt with them, challenge the rules of the game. Tragedy
does not depict man as a helpless puppet dancing to the strings of destiny, The
tragic vision does not assure man's ultimate downfall. Instead, it explores ways in
which free will exerts itself in the world. The determination to act rather then
submit often leads to disastrous results but at the same time it tests the basic
substance of humanity. This tremendous strength of will to scale the heights and
accomplish the impossible sets the hero apart from the ordinary humanity but
inspires us with a vision of human potential. Thus tragedy far from being a pessimistic
view of life, is ultimately optimistic about the value of human achievement and the
unconquerable strength of human spirit. To put into Eric Bentley's words. "Tragedy
cannot entail extreme pessimism, for that would be to lose faith in Man." The tragic
vision encompasses the paradox of human freedom, admitting the possibility of
great goodness and great evil.
26
ome of the kinds of tragedy are: Different Qpes of Drama
) Revenge tragedy or the tragedy of blood which derives from Seneca its
materials of murder, revenge, ghosts, mutilation and carnage. It was a dramatic
genre that flourished in the late Elizabethan and Jacobean period. Kyd's The
Spani~hTragedy (1586) established this popular form, later to be followed by
Marlowe's The .Jew of Malta (1592)' Webster's The Duchess of M a w
( 1 6 12) and Shakespeare's Hamlet (1602).
i) Domestic tragedy was written in prose and presented a protagonist from the
middle or lower social ranks who suffer a commonplace or domestic disaster.
This was popularized by eighteenth century writers. For example, George
Lillo's The London Merchant.
iii) Social tragedy revolved around an issue of general social or political
significance. These represent middle class or working class heroes and heroines.
Notable tragedies of nineteenth and twentieth centuries are Henrik Ibsen's A
Doll's House and, Ghosts, and Arthur Millers Death of a Salesmen (1949).
iv) Melodrama: originally applied to musical plays including opera. The protagonists
are flat types. Here drama relies on implausible events and sensational action.
Continuous action drives the plot through a series of adventures. It thrives on
thrills. ekcitement, suspense and rescues. The conflict is external and everything
is delineated as black or white. Melodrama appears to deal with serious
subjects, but its seriousness is only pretence. Most of the serious dramas never
reach the heights of tragedy and thus become melodramas. Adventure films
are examples of this.
v) Romantic tragedy: Romances which end unhappily or with the death of the
hero and heroine are categorised as romantic tragedies e.g. Shakespeare's
Romeo and Juliet.
vi) Heroic drama: Heroic dramas may not look deeply into the philosophical
questions of good, evil, man's relation to supernatural, etc. but they abide by
the rule of poetic justice and portray swash-bucking adventures. e.g. The
Count of Monte Cristo.
4.3 COMEDY
At the most fundamental level, comedy focuses on pleasure and amusement. The
spectators are made to feel confident that no great disaster will occur and usually
the action turns out to be happy for all.
Allardyce Nicoll describes three techniques of comedy which create a comic
detachment (i.e. we laugh at the hardships of comic characters because the author
sets them at a psychological distance): derision, incongruity and automatism.
Derision takes aim at human frailties such as stupidity, hypocrisy and arrogance,
knocking the victim off his self-built pedestal. The character too pretends more,
thus setti& himself up for the fall. With insults and sarcasm, comedy's sharp writ
seeks to pierce the over-inflated egos of pompous politicians, bragging generals and
haughty aristocrats. Derision creates distance by placing its subjects beneath us as
contemptible and foolish. Shakespeare's Twelfth Night is a classic example of this.
Incongruity provokes laughter by means of ridiculous contrast in situation, character
or dialogue. The unexpected element takes us by surprise. Misplaced words or
statements are also a source of laughter. For instance, Shakespeare's A Midsummer
Night k Dream or Gogol's The Inspector General.
Automatism occurs when people are depicted as acting without thinking. Comic
characters often have annoying habits or mannerisms. They lose the ability to
interact naturally. For example, Chekhov's The Marriage Proposal. 27
Drama: An Introduction Comedies make use of several of the traditional roles. They tend to portray characters
as recognizable stereotypes. Comic characters remain on the other side of line
separating fiction from reality. This aesthetic distance allows us to laugh at their
troubles without feeling pity and fear of tragedy. The world of comedy is characterized
by absence of real pain. For all its criticism of human limitations, hypocrisy and
foolishness, comedy views human beings as survivors. In comedy we laugh at our
shortcomings and learn from our failures.
In his work on ethics, Aristotle describes two types of contrasting characters. The
braggart (alazon) pretends to be more than he is, while the ironist (eiron) seems to
be less than he is. Aristotle defined comedy as written about persons of minor
importance whom their faults rendered ridiculous. The pair of crafty schemer and
the parasite was one of the most popular plots. This can be witnessed in Jonson's
Volpone (1606) where Volpone and Mosca trick others out of money and wives
both. Similarly Horner in The Country Wi$e (1675).
Within the broad spectrum of comedy the following types are often distinguished:
ii) Comedy of Manners is the most prominent form of high comedy as it holds
the customs of aristocratic society up to ridicule. It uses verbal wit and sarcasm
to depict the charm and reveal the pretensions of its characters. It exhibits two
contrasting impulses: to celebrate and to criticize. The comic vision professes
both hope and discouragement about the human condition, looking for the best
but expecting the worst. It originated in the New Comedy of the Greek
Menander as distinguished from the Old Comedy ofAristophanes. Shakespeare's
Loves Labour Lost and Much Ado About Nothing are examples of comedy
of manners. The comedy of manners, as its name implies, concentrates upon
the depiction of men and women living in a social world ruled by convention.
Its manners are not simply the behaviour of humanity in general but the
affectations and cultured veneer of a highly developed and self-conscious
group. Intellectual refinement, epigrammatic wit and easy dalliance had been
made the prime qualities sought after by the gallants and their mistresses. At
the same time, it tends to tone down and to intellectualize ordinary emotions.
This form of comedy was given a high polish in Restoration Comedy (1660-
28 1700), and is much indebted to French writer Moliere (1622-73). It deals with
the relations and intrigues of men and women living in a sophisticated upper Different 'Qpes of Drama
class society and relies for comic effect on the wit and sparkle of the dialogue
often in the form of repartees. Each person tries to cap the remark of the
other, or to turn it to his or her our advantage William Congreve's The Way of
the World (1700) and William Wycherley's The Country Wife (1675) are
classic examples of mastery of wit.
iii) Sentimental comedy grew out of this comedy of manners. It represented the
lSh century middle class life and its reaction against what had come to be
considered the immorality of a situation and indecency of dialogue. Goldsmith's
She Stoops to Conquer, Sheridan's The Rivals and A School for Scandal
and Wilde's The Importance of Being Ernest deleted the indecency, revived
the wit and gaiety of Restoration comedy.
iv) Cornedy of Humour was a type of comedy developed by Ben Jonson based
on the ancient physiological theory of the 'few humours' the primary fluids i.e.
blood, phlegm, choler (yellow bile) and melancholy (black bite) whose mixture
was held to determine both a person's physical condition and character type.
Thomas Shadwell had a flair and skill in depicting humorous types. This is also
called the 'satiric comedy' or the 'corrective comedy'. It tends to see the dark
side of humanity and uses laughter as a satiric weapon. Jonson's Volpone is
an example of this comedy which exposes the false premises on which people
4.4 TRAGI-COMEDY
Accord~ngto Horace Walpole, "Life is a comedy to those who think, a tragedy to
those who feel". Not all plays fit into a single category; in fact most plays consist of
elements from two or more genres. It was a type of Elizabethan and Jacobean
drama which intermingled both the standard characters and subject matter and the
standard plots of tragedy and comedy. People were of high degree and low degree
and the plot was serious criticism with lowbrow farce and slapstick humour.
Fletcher's The Faithful Shepherdess (1 6 10)' Shakespeare's Merchant of Venice
and The Winter k Tale are popular tragicomic romances. It is thus defined as an
interpretation of emotional reaction where tragedy and comedy are both present yet
one does not merely follow upon the other but arises from it.
One of the first dramatists to explain tragicomedy as a uniquely modem world view,
Friedrich Duerrenmatt (1921-1990) felt that the 2 0 century
~ was an era lying in the
shadow of two wars, and the Holocaust, and could no longer support the spirit of
exaltation and therefore the true reflection of modem humanity is a paradox in
which the tragic is depicted as comic; thus man is like a circus clown with a sad
face, whose actions appear comical but the implication of ultimate meaninglessness
behind those action came closer to tragic despair.
Drama: An Introduction
4.5 HISTORY PLAYS
Chronicle plays were dramatic works based on the historical materials in the
English Chronicles by Raphael Holinshed and others. Chronicles were written
accounts in prose or verse, of national or worldwide events. These works achieved
high popularity in the sixteenth century. The early chronicle plays were a loosely-
knit series of historical events and depended for effect on stage battles. Public was
fascinated by these historical dramas. The dramatic presentation of historical events
such as Julius Caesal; Richard II , Edward I, Henry V are popular Elizabethan
historical plays and recent examples are Arthur Miller's The Crucible (1 953) and
Robert Bolts' A Man for All Seasons (1962). The concern with history committed
the playwright to deal with all sorts of situations, ambiguities and apparent
irrelevancies. The fusion of the outer (events) and inner (character) i.e. the close
interdependence of action and character brings the dramatic effect.
f
harata analyses acting into four components:
Acting through the body (angika), relating to gestures and movements.
. Acting through speech (vacika), relating to voice intonation, recitation and
singing.
. Acting through accessories (aharya), such as makeup, costume, jewellery,
props.
. Acting through signs of emotion (suttvika), relating to the physical manifestation
of emotional states such as tears,,,,,.(Miller: 18).
Gestures function to make vivid pictures, to communicate motions and emotions and
therefore must not be mechanical but graceful and spontaneous. "In the Indian
theatre acting is considered a discipline (yoga) where the actor and acted became
one. Arduous training is essential to the perfect acting (abhinaya) that can produce
/aesthetic experience (rasa)". (Miller: 19).
Nature functions as a setting as well as a representative of creation and destruction
of life. The eight essential principles of empirical existence -air, water, earth, fire,
ether, the sun, the moon and the ritual sacrifice express Siva (ardhanarisvara) -
the male and the female; the purusa and prakriti; Siva and Parvati. These concepts
are the basic tenets of Kalidasa's drama.The Indian drama begins with an invocation
and a proiogue (prastavana). The invocation of the recital of Nandi suggests the
gist of the plot. The Prelude may begin with a brief allusion to the poets' literary
attainment, his genealogy etc; the Sutradhara (Chorus) suggests the subject, names
the character about to enter and pleases the audience with sweet songs descriptive
of some season. The prelude marks a transition to the action of drama itself. The
swift rhytlims give way to dialogue, poetry and action. This also sets the zones on
the stage that represent different realms of the dramatic universe. The whole
matter is well- determined and divided into Acts and Scenes. An act must not be
toolong and should be full of rasa. The play should end with a Benediction or
prayer (Bharatvakya). The language used by the hero and the higher character is
Classical Sanskrit, while female and other minor characters speak in the different
Prakrit dialects. The plot should be drawn from real life; the Hero must be of
ministerial rank or a Brahman; the Heroine may be a maiden of a noble family or a
courtesan, and the character to be represented should be celestial as well as
human. It is observed that the characteristic peculiarities of the Indian drama are
mainly three - 1) its peculiar structure, 2) the absence of the distinction between
comedy and tragedy and 3) the diversity of language spoken by the characters. The
Sanskrit verses are rich in imagery and metaphor and follow the aesthetic norms
whereas the Prakrit verses are lyrical, expressive and imaginative.
The hero in each play is a king and it is through the king that the natural, social and
divine worlds unite. The King's spiritual powers can be equated with his martial
strength and moral superiority. He is the royal sage. His responsibility is to guide
and protect those beneath him. The heroine of drama is the vehicle for transforming
erotic passion into aesthetic experience.
Drama: An Introduction Kalidasa's literary reputation is based on his six surviving works : Malavikagninzitra
(~Malavika and Agninlitrtr); Vikranforvasiya (Urvusi won by valour);
AbhijnanaLsakut~talum~S(rkuntuluand the Ring of Recollection); Meghdzltu
(The Cloud messenger); Raghuvanrsu (The Lineage of Raghu) and Kunzara
Sanzblznva (The Birth of Siva's "?on).Coherent language, poetic technique; style
and sentiment makes Kalidasa the acknowledged master poet of Sanskrit. The
heroines are endowed with physical fornis, language, dance movement and magical
relations to nature. The heroes are also connoisseurs of natural beauty and art. The
audience tends to forget the everyday world and enters the fantastic realm of
imagination. His plays are also known as the "Theatre of Memory" for tnelnory
is crucial to the production of romantic sentiment throughout Sanskrit literature.
Miller writes : "... memory has the power to break tlirougll the logic of everyday
experience - it makes visible what is invisible, obliterates distances, rekerses
chronologies, and fuses what is ordinarily separate" (Miller : 39 - 40).
David Gitomer describes the playhouse as follows:
...most attention is given to the medium rectangular variety ... .Ninety-six
feet in length, forty-eight in width, but divided so that equal halves were given
over to audience and performers, these halls could have acco~nmodatedno
more than 200 spectators sitting on a mat-covered floor with benches for the
distinguished and elderly on the sides. Wooden pillars supported the roof,
wliich was thatched. At least few of these pillars stood away from the walls
within the audience area. Each was associated with one of the four classes
(vurnas) . . .
The part of the house wliich was the domain of tlie perfonner was again
subdivided.... there was a wall between the backstage area and the stage,
with two doonvays cut near the centre for entrances and exits.. ...there were
sliding curtains over these doors ......between the doors were two large
drums; clustered around them were the other musicians of tlie ensemble,
which seems to have provided an almost continuous accompaniment to any
dance-drama ....the actual playing area may have been as small as twelve
feet square; another scheme works out ta a rectangular 24' x 12'. ...
Every aspect of the construction of the playhouses, fro111tlie laying of the
string to measure the foundation to the drawing of a mandala for the
installation and worship of gods in the building, was part of a great ritual,
undertaken at tlie proper astrological moment, which drew on traditional
modes of vedic sacrifice . . . (Miller : 63 - 65).
The stage becomes a fluid space in which divisions are established by dialogue and
movement, highlighted by lights and costumes and tlie audience transported through
earthly and cosmic spaces.
From the time of Kalidasa to tlie present times poetic drama or verse play is
popular on the Indian stage. Verse plays like Batalvi's Lunu or love legends of
Laila-Majnu, Scrssi-Punu and Heer-Rarqhu be long to a single cultural tradition
and seek to teach didactic and moral lessons. The epical rnodes of Eastern epic
have remained dependent on estabiished and elitist notions. With the passage of
time imaginative construction gave way to a new direction in literarj creation which
amounts to flouting of the tradition and searching for new meanings and
interpretations.