Finnegans Wake and GREEKS
Finnegans Wake and GREEKS
The literary achievement of James Joyce is inconceivable apart from its many and
varied elements of Greek origin. Joyce was profoundly influenced by Greek literature,
language, mythology and philosophy. He enthused about all things Greek, classical
and contemporary, and owed many of his deepest inspirations to Hellenic influences.
Homer was Joyce’s favourite storyteller, providing the motif, model and structure for
Ulysses in which Leopold Bloom, the new-age Odysseus, reenacts his epic journey
through the modern cityscape of Dublin.
Joyce regarded Aristotle as ‘the greatest thinker of all times’, and studied his writings
assiduously. The Greek philosopher was one of the principal sources for Joyce’s
aesthetic; he provided, moreover, the categories with which Stephen Dedalus, Joyce’s
largely autobiographic character, interpreted everyday life and experience.
In the foreign cities where he lived, Joyce sought out the company of Greeks,
believing them to be the natural inheritors of an ancient legacy. In this paper I will
refer summarily to the importance for Joyce of Homer and Aristotle, to Joyce’s
dealings with modern Greeks, and finally to his knowledge of modern Greek.1 [1]
The name given by Joyce to his literary alter ego, in both A Portrait of the Artist as a
Young Man and Ulysses—‘Stephen Dedalus’—is itself a conscious claim by the
author to his ancient Hellenic legacy.
The composite name refers both to the first Christian martyr, and to the creator of the
labyrinth—Joyce was familiar with Arthur Evans’ excavations at the time.[2]
Joyce’s first reference to Greece occurs in A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man,
where Stephen’s first holy communion is described:
“When the rector had stooped down to give him the holy communion he had smelt a
faint winy smell off the rector’s breath after the wine of the mass. The word was
beautiful: wine. It made you think of dark purple because the grapes were dark purple
that grew in Greece outside houses like white temples.’[3]
Στο έργο τoυ: Finnegans Wake (Αγρύπνια των Φίννεγκαν), ο Τζόυς, ανασκάπτει και
φέρνει στην επιφάνεια την μυθολογία των αρχαίων Ελλήνων, για την γέννηση των
θεών, σε έναν παραλληλισμό της οικογένειας των Φίννεγκαν.
Στην ελληνική μυθολογία της Θεογονίας (Ησίοδος):
1
Uranus's strongest son, Cronus (the Roman Saturn), murders his father and castrates
him with an enormous sickle--"an exitous erseroyal Deo Jupto." (FW, 353.18; 'exit of
the once royal god, Jove').
This occurs in the "golden age" of Greece, or the divine age in the Viconian cycle
(NS, 69). Gold is also the color Clive Hart assigns to this age. (Structure and Motif,
19)
The Wakean family's genesis also begins with the usurpation of power by a stronger,
younger heir.
The scope of HCE's character is so immense that it includes Tim Finnegan and all the
manifestations of him that recirculate in the living world--"the father of
fornicationists." (FW, 4.12)
Similarily, in the male line of Greek gods, the heir must commit "regicide" (FW,
162.01) in order to make room for the new regime—
Each of these Joves reigns over their particular regime, and all religions of the world
have a Jove. (NS, 9)
Anna Livia is the wife of HCE, and is similarily Gaea or Juno to the male god,
representing fertility, Mother Earth, and symbolizes the river, as in Yeats' Easter
1916.
The fertility of Haveth Childers Everywhere (HCE) and Anna Livia Plurabella (ALP)
creates dualities -- the dipolar opposite brothers, Shem and Shaun, and the leap-year
girl, Isabel, who is very different from her mother.
In A Portrait, Dante threatens young Stephen, who is crouched on all fours under the
dinnertable, "Apologise, if not, the eagles will come and pull out your eyes." (AP, 8)
Dante thereafter instills piety and fear in Stephen.
Vico believed that the fear of divinity arises in all nations from Jove's discipline of
Prometheus, (NS, 503) who, chained to Mount Caucasus, is visited daily by a vulture
who devours his liver, only for it to grow back the next day, continuing the cycle until
the day Hercules unbinds him. Stephen's terrore defixi that causes him to recite the
chiasmic chant, "Pull out his eyes, Apologise, Apologise, Pull out his eyes," is the
same fear induced by the first thunder that drives bestial man to caves to begin
civilized institutions --"Cave!" (FW, 16.3)--and Joyce to his closet saying "papa!" to
create the institution of language. (NS, 387)
Since Joyce, Stephen, and Shem are all sons of the father figures of John Joyce,
Simon Dedalus, and Earwicker, a parallel with Jove's son,
Prometheus, holds throughout.
In the Mutt and Jute episode, Shem and Shaun become the primordial opposite
brothers, Prometheus and Epimetheus, "furrowards [and] bagawards." (FW, 18.32).
The Letter written by Shem "the Punman" becomes Finnegans Wake and, in effect,
the body of Joyce as much as Ulysses had.
But before Shem can compose the Letter and before the reader can decipher it, we
must evolve to the language of Vico's human age marked by the use of vulgar letters
(NS, 32).
Shem, as Prometheus, must bring the vulgar "allaphbed" to humans in order to read
the "claybook" (FW, 18.17;
Shem, as Mutt, whispers the secret to Jute: "He who runes may rede it on all fours."
(FW, 18.05)
At Mount Caucasus, or "causcaus," (FW, 378.15) that "original hen" picks at the pile
of peat, pecking at the the entrails of the shackled sun-bringer, Prometheus, with "the
last remains of an outdoor meal by some unknown sunseeker." (FW, 110.29)
Shem, like Joyce, becomes the body of his art, and as Shaun relates, "his liver too is
great value, a spatiality." (FW, 172.09; 'specialty')
Shaun also describes Shem with "a loose liver," (FW, 169.17) perhaps because it
eaten daily--an artist's suffering, "mystery man of the pork martyrs."
The liver was also special to Vico, representing bestial man's desires. As the blood
center, the liver is the "conglomerate of passions of all animals." (NS, 701)
"a gulp apologetic, healing his tare be the smeyle of his oye, oogling around. Him
belly no belong sollow mole pigeon. Ally bully. Fu Li's gulpa. . . Moe like that only
he stopped short in looking up up upfrom his tide shackled wrists through the ghost of
an ocean's . . . scruting foreback into the fargoneahead to feel out what age in years
tropical." (FW, 426.15-23)
The "sollow mole pigeon," Belinda the Hen, that has been pecking at the giant's
insides, shows her identity as a bullying ALP.
The reason for Shem's gastrocrucifixion and martyrdom is shown to be man's happy
fault (L. O felix culpa), perhaps that is why Shem has a "smeyle" in his eye.
In the Triv and Quad chapter (II.2), the matching section at the end matches
'Prometheus' with 'Santa Claus.' (FW, 307.L20, 307.16)
If Prometheus hadn't given the gift of fire, then Santa Claus couldn't deliver gifts via a
chimney.
Another of Shem's identities is Nick, the devil, which is very close to Saint Nicholas,
who becomes Santa Claus (or just mix the letters of 'Santa' into 'Satan').
She leaps about traveling on the "regginbrow" and her self-reflective "Nursing
Mirror" (FW, 46.25) shows the raw material of the mind of which the dream of
Finnegans Wake is made, memory.
"In effect, I remumble, from the yules gone by, purr lil murerof myhind." (FW,
295.04)
She emulates the sister of the two primordial giants, Mnemosyne--"knew well in
precious memory and that proud grace to her." (FW, 317.36).
She embodies the creative spirit, "ars we say in the classsies. Kunstful, we others
said." (FW, 357.15; Ger Kunst, art)
"blackout[s]," (FW, 617.14) such as in: "O'c'stle, n'c'stle, tr'c'stle, crumbling!," (FW,
18.05) and "m'm'ry." (FW, 460.20)
Mutt, thinking about Dublin's Rathmines, where Joyce grew up, swears,
"I trumple from rath in mine mines when I rimimirim!" (FW, 16.27; Ger. erinnern,
remember)
The family cycle continues as the Viconian historical cycles turn, "Gyre O, gyre O,
gyrotundo!" (FW, 295.23)
Prometheus's son, Deucalion, and Epimetheus' daughter, Pyrrha, become the new
Adam and Eve, HCE and ALP.
In the new cycle, man is created again by the domesticism of marriage where, "in the
names of Deucalion and Pyrrha," (179.09) stones (bestial man, Jute) are throne over
their shoulders to become civilized men (Mutt). (NS, 79)
της Θεογονίας του Ησιόδου. μυθολογίες που περιλαμβάνουν όλη την ανθρώπινη
ιστορική εμπειρία.
Works Cited.
AP Joyce, James. A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man. Viking Press : New York,
1968.
NS Vico, Giambattista. The New Science of Giambattista Vico. 3rd ed. (1744). trans.
by Bergin, T. G. and Fisch, M. H. Cornell University Press : London, 1991.
Hart, Clive. Structure and Motif in Finnegans Wake. Northwestern University Press,
1971. Finnegans Wake: Greek Influence
Finnegans Wake exhumes mythologies and theologies of cultures encompassing the
whole of human experience. Not the least researched are references and
correspondences to classical mythology, but the family of gods in the Greek creation
myth offers a unique parallel to Joyce's ever-expansive Wakean family. In doing so, I
will use as a guide a scholar of both classical mythology and the institution of family,
Giambattista Vico.
In the Greek creation myth (and also in Genesis), an unnammable god divided
timeless and formless Chaos--"joepeter's gaseytotum" (FW, 426.21; 'Jupiter's gaseous
universe,' L totum)-- into heaven and earth, the male Uranus and female Gaea. Uranus
"the Rainmaker" (FW, 87.06) impregnates Gaea's clefts and rivervalleys with
rainwater, spawning the powerful Titans, or the Giants, which are etymologically
"sons of Earth." (NS, 13) Uranus's strongest son, Cronus (the Roman Saturn), murders
his father and castrates him with an enormous sickle--"an exitous erseroyal Deo
Jupto." (FW, 353.18; 'exit of the once royal god, Jove'). This occurs in the "golden
age" of Greece, or the divine age in the Viconian cycle (NS, 69). Gold is also the
color Clive Hart assigns to this age. (Structure and Motif, 19)
The Wakean family's genesis also begins with the usurpation of power by a stronger,
younger heir. Tim Finnegan, the god-like giant is replaced by Humphrey Chimpden
Earwicker, or HCE, representing all heroes and mock-heroes. The scope of HCE's
character is so immense that it includes Tim Finnegan and all the manifestations of
him that recirculate in the living world--"the father of fornicationists." (FW, 4.12)
Similarily, in the male line of Greek gods, the heir must commit "regicide" (FW,
162.01) in order to make room for the new regime--Cronus castrates Uranus, Father
Sky, to become Father Time, Zeus kills Cronus in the Gigantomachy to become
Thundergod. Each of these Joves reigns over their particular regime, and all religions
of the world have a Jove. (NS, 9) Anna Livia is the wife of HCE, and is similarily
Gaea or Juno to the male god, representing fertility, Mother Earth, and symbolizes the
river, as in Yeats' Easter 1916. The fertility of Haveth Childers Everywhere and Anna
Livia Plurabella creates dualities -- the dipolar opposite brothers, Shem and Shaun,
and the leap-year girl, Isabel, who is very different from her mother.
In A Portrait, Dante threatens young Stephen, who is crouched on all fours under the
dinnertable, "Apologise, if not, the eagles will come and pull out your eyes." (AP, 8)
Dante thereafter instills piety and fear in Stephen. Vico believed that the fear of
divinity arises in all nations from Jove's discipline of Prometheus, (NS, 503) who,
chained to Mount Caucasus, is visited daily by a vulture who devours his liver, only
for it to grow back the next day, continuing the cycle until the day Hercules unbinds
him. Stephen's terrore defixi that causes him to recite the chiasmic chant, "Pull out his
eyes, Apologise, Apologise, Pull out his eyes," is the same fear induced by the first
thunder that drives bestial man to caves to begin civilized institutions --"Cave!" (FW,
16.3)--and Joyce to his closet saying "papa!" to create the institution of language.
(NS, 387)
Since Joyce, Stephen, and Shem are all sons of the father figures of John Joyce,
Simon Dedalus, and Earwicker, a parallel with Jove's son, Prometheus, holds
throughout. In the Mutt and Jute episode, Shem and Shaun become the primordial
opposite brothers, Prometheus and Epimetheus, "furrowards [and] bagawards." (FW,
18.32).
The Letter written by Shem "the Punman" becomes Finnegans Wake and, in effect,
the body of Joyce as much as Ulysses had. But before Shem can compose the Letter
and before the reader can decipher it, we must evolve to the language of Vico's human
age marked by the use of vulgar letters (NS, 32). Shem, as Prometheus, must bring the
vulgar "allaphbed" to humans in order to read the "claybook" (FW, 18.17; as
Prometheus also molds his four-legged humans from clay). Shem, as Mutt, whispers
the secret to Jute: "He who runes may rede it on all fours." (FW, 18.05) The runes
propogate in primordial man by "Gutenmorg's" "wordpress" through many "misses in
prints" until the tale of another prostrate, shackled Titan is "bound" as the "book of
Doublends Jined," Finn MacCool. (FW, 10.07-16)
At Mount Caucasus, or "causcaus," (FW, 378.15) that "original hen" picks at the pile
of peat, pecking at the the entrails of the shackled sun-bringer, Prometheus, with "the
last remains of an outdoor meal by some unknown sunseeker." (FW, 110.29) Shem,
like Joyce, becomes the body of his art, and as Shaun relates, "his liver too is great
value, a spatiality." (FW, 172.09; 'specialty') Shaun also describes Shem with "a loose
liver," (FW, 169.17) perhaps because it eaten daily--an artist's suffering, "mystery
man of the pork martyrs." The liver was also special to Vico, representing bestial
man's desires. As the blood center, the liver is the "conglomerate of passions of all
animals." (NS, 701) An important step in the creation of civilized man is eradicating
man's bestial tendancy. Therefore, when that "gnarlybird ygather[s]" the "all spoiled
goods" (FW, 10.32, 11.18) from the giant outlined aslumber, she consumes man's
bestial nature and leaves the fear of god injected by the first Thunderword to engender
the pious, civilized man.
"a gulp apologetic, healing his tare be the smeyle of his oye, oogling around. Him
belly no belong sollow mole pigeon. Ally bully. Fu Li's gulpa. . . Moe like that only
he stopped short in looking up up upfrom his tide shackled wrists through the ghost of
an ocean's . . . scruting foreback into the fargoneahead to feel out what age in years
tropical." (FW, 426.15-23)
In the Triv and Quad chapter (II.2), the matching section at the end matches
'Prometheus' with 'Santa Claus.' (FW, 307.L20, 307.16) If Prometheus hadn't given
the gift of fire, then Santa Claus couldn't deliver gifts via a chimney. Another of
Shem's identities is Nick, the devil, which is very close to Saint Nicholas, who
becomes Santa Claus (or just mix the letters of 'Santa' into 'Satan').
Isabel is a freer unfettered spirit than her brothers. She leaps about traveling on the
"regginbrow" and her self-reflective "Nursing Mirror" (FW, 46.25) shows the raw
material of the mind of which the dream of Finnegans Wake is made, memory. "In
effect, I remumble, from the yules gone by, purr lil murerof myhind." (FW, 295.04)
She emulates the sister of the two primordial giants, Mnemosyne--"knew well in
precious memory and that proud grace to her." (FW, 317.36). Her temperament is like
that of mnemonics, fanciful and erratic--"balbly call to memory." (FW, 37.16; L
balbus, 'stuttering') She embodies the creative spirit, "ars we say in the classsies.
Kunstful, we others said." (FW, 357.15; Ger Kunst, art) As Vico writes, "imagination
is nothing but the springing up again of reminiscences. (NS, 699) Isabel's twenty-
eight schoolfriends, the "daughters of February," (FW, 470.04) are an extended
panorama of the Greek Muses, covering all the new arts of the modern world. "She
has a gift of seek in site and she allcasually ansars helpers, the dreamydears." (FW,
5.25) When memory degenerates there are many "blackout[s]," (FW, 617.14) such as
in: "O'c'stle, n'c'stle, tr'c'stle, crumbling!," (FW, 18.05) and "m'm'ry." (FW, 460.20)
Mutt, thinking about Dublin's Rathmines, where Joyce grew up, swears, "I trumple
from rath in mine mines when I rimimirim!" (FW, 16.27; Ger. erinnern, remember)
The family cycle continues as the Viconian historical cycles turn, "Gyre O, gyre O,
gyrotundo!" (FW, 295.23) Prometheus's son, Deucalion, and Epimetheus' daughter,
Pyrrha, become the new Adam and Eve, HCE and ALP. In the new cycle, man is
created again by the domesticism of marriage where, "in the names of Deucalion and
Pyrrha," (179.09) stones (bestial man, Jute) are throne over their shoulders to become
civilized men (Mutt). (NS, 79)
Works Cited.
AP Joyce, James. A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man. Viking Press : New York,
1968.
NS Vico, Giambattista. The New Science of Giambattista Vico. 3rd ed. (1744). trans.
by Bergin, T. G. and Fisch, M. H. Cornell University Press : London, 1991.
Hart, Clive. Structure and Motif in Finnegans Wake. Northwestern University Press,
1971.