Opinion | AustralianPolitics.com

It’s Over: Defeat Looms For The Rudd Government

Aug 19, 2013

by Malcolm Farnsworth

After Kevin Rudd’s return to the prime ministership on June 27, and throughout July, I told anyone who asked that I thought the electoral psychology of Rudd’s revival wasn’t clear. I wanted to wait until the end of July to see what the polls revealed.

It seems clear now that the country breathed a sigh of relief that Gillard was gone. The electorate was also prepared to give Rudd a chance to show his stuff. There was a general sense of excitement that we now had a contest. [Read more…]

Filed Under: 2013 Federal Election, A.L.P., Opinion, Rudd Tagged With: 2013 Federal Election, A.L.P., Kevin Rudd, Tony Abbott

Alternative Universes And The PNG Solution

Jul 20, 2013

Alternative universes abounded last night.

But sometimes the media worlds available via a remote control are more alike than they are willing to pretend.

There was the ABC. Within an hour of Kevin Rudd’s announcement of the PNG solution, its screen was filled with refugee advocates castigating the decision. They were joined by frothing right-wingers in an unholy unity ticket of condemnation.

Online, in the ever-so-slightly-nutty world of Twitter, there was talk of White Australia, racism and Labor’s shame. Dire warnings of malaria and rape coalesced with suddenly-expert analyses of the state of civil society in PNG.

Some lamented the shape-shifting Rudd and yearned for The Great Gillard.

There was Sky News, sadly these days a paradise for ever-more vacuous right-wing talk show hosts and those cable-friendly Laborites who make you worry that you might be on the same side.

As on the ABC, the resident Liberals and standalone right-wingers were especially lathered and frenzied. Last night they were born-again campaigners for the down-trodden. They accepted the solution but despaired of its implementation.

I felt somewhat alone. In my foolishness, I thought I might just have witnessed a political masterstroke. Commentators online suggested otherwise. I should be more ashamed, they seemed to say. [Read more…]

Filed Under: 2013 Federal Election, A.L.P., Gillard, Opinion, Refugees, Rudd, Twitter Tagged With: asylum seekers, Kevin Rudd, refugees, Scott Morrison, Tony Abbott

Where Are The Seats Rudd Needs To Win?

Jul 03, 2013

The “sugar hit” polls are in. It’s 52-48, perhaps 51-49. We have a contest.

Don’t we?

Labor starts with 72 seats, including the notionally independent Dobell. It needs 76 seats in the 150-seat House of Representatives. It needs to hold everything it has and pick up 4 more seats to govern with an outright majority of one.

Let’s assume for the moment that the ALP can hold all its 72 seats. Yes, it’s a mighty big assumption.

Where might four more seats come from?

TASMANIA

Labor holds 4 of the 5 seats in the Apple Isle. The only seat it doesn’t hold is Denison. Unlike the other independents who backed Julia Gillard, Andrew Wilkie is trying for another term.

Denison is based on Hobart. It has very strong Labor areas and strong Greens areas. Recent polls suggest Wilkie is polling strongly and has lifted his primary vote from 21.26% in 2010 to the mid-30s now. He could be hard to beat.

Other reports and polls have Labor on the nose in Tasmania. But Labor has won all 5 seats in Tasmania in 3 of the past 5 elections (1998, 2001 and 2007). Beyond that, you have to go back to 1974 to find a fourth occasion.

VICTORIA

Labor is at a historically high point in Victoria. It polled 55.31% of the two-party-preferred vote in 2010. Despite losing Melbourne to the Greens, the ALP picked up La Trobe and McEwen, giving it 22 of the 37 seats, or 59.4%.

Assuming it holds those 22, it can look to Melbourne as a possibility. The Liberals are likely to direct preferences to the ALP. Unless Adam Bandt can lift his primary vote by several points above the 36.17% he secured in 2010, he is unlikely to win. [Read more…]

Filed Under: 2013 Federal Election, A.L.P., Liberal Party, Opinion, Rudd Tagged With: 2013 Federal Election, A.L.P., Julia Gillard, Kevin Rudd, Liberal Party

Woof Woof!

Jun 03, 2013

I can’t resist it. Whenever I hear someone say “woof woof”, I always think of a famous exchange between Gough Whitlam and Billy Snedden in 1975.

Today’s email from Crikey alerted me to this tweet from Prime Minister Julia Gillard on Saturday:

At least Gillard was only expressing her delight at the 9-point victory by the Western Bulldogs over Port Adelaide.

In the House of Representatives on February 19, 1975, however, the same words were uttered by the Liberal Opposition Leader, Billy Snedden. They came during a discussion of one of the most contentious constitutional issues of the Whitlam years. Snedden was ridiculed by Whitlam and the incident contributed to Liberal unease over Snedden’s leadership. He was replaced by Malcolm Fraser a couple of weeks later. [Read more…]

Filed Under: Gillard, Opinion, Political History, Whitlam Tagged With: Billy Snedden, casual Senate vacancies, Gough Whitlam, Joh Bjelke-Petersen, Julia Gillard, Tom Lewis, woof woof

2013 Federal Election: How Many Seats Will Labor Lose?

Jun 02, 2013

An election defeat of historic proportions seems to be looming for the Gillard Labor government.

As a rule, I’m more interested in trying to explain an election result after we know the outcome. However, let’s take a stab at predicting the result.

I don’t regard these predictions as particularly startling or original. They are based on the published opinion polls, assorted news items and anecdotal reports. In some cases, I have local knowledge. In others, I’m influenced by historical results. Often, I’m just guessing. Don’t take it too seriously.

Some assumptions and explanations:

I believe the Gillard government is going to lose and lose badly. I believe this outcome has been certain for the past two years.
All of the published opinion polls (Newspoll, Nielsen, Essential, Galaxy, Morgan) have been showing a 4-6% swing against the ALP for most of the past two years. Seats in New South Wales, Queensland and Western Australia are particularly at risk and the swing is expected to be much greater in Labor areas. Rural and regional areas have turned decisively against Labor. During this year, an emerging view has Tasmania, South Australia and Victoria joining the trend, after having swung toward the ALP in 2010. On this basis, I expect the ALP’s result to be worse than 1996, probably closer to 1975. It could be worse than 1975. I expect the ALP to lose a minimum of 25 seats. CLICK HERE for tables showing the ALP’s federal election record.
I don’t expect any members of the Coalition parties to lose their seats. My starting point for the Coalition is 73 seats, including Peter Slipper in Fisher and Tony Crook in O’Connor. Both of these men will be replaced by new members.
The ALP goes into the election with 72 seats, including Craig Thomson’s seat of Dobell. Thomson currently sits as an independent. The tables below deal only with those 72 seats.
In addition to the 145 seats held by the ALP and the Coalition, another 4 are held by independents and 1 by the Greens. There are 150 seats up for election.
The electorate of Melbourne is the only seat I think it is possible for the ALP to pick up. If the Greens member, Adam Bandt, can improve his primary vote, he may win, even if the Liberals preference Labor. This will be one to watch on the night.
CLICK HERE to see a colour-coded table of election outcomes in each seat for the past 10 elections.

ALP SEATS MOST LIKELY TO BE LOST (28)

These seats are the ALP’s most marginal. However, it includes some seats once regarded as safe Labor, particularly in NSW. It seems to be generally accepted that the ALP is doing especially badly in NSW, so I have given away all of its rural seats and made a call on others that don’t seem marginal on the swing.

A.L.P. SEATS MOST LIKELY TO BE LOST (28)
No.	SEAT	STATE	MEMBER	MARGIN %
1.	Banks	NSW	Daryl Melham	1.5
2.	Barton	NSW	Robert McClelland (retiring)	6.9
3.	Dobell	NSW	Craig Thomson (suspended)	5.1
4.	Eden-Monaro	NSW	Mike Kelly	4.2
5.	Greenway	NSW	Michelle Rowland	0.9
6.	Kingsford-Smith	NSW	Peter Garrett	5.2
7.	Lindsay	NSW	David Bradbury	1.1
8.	Page	NSW	Janelle Saffin	4.2
9.	Parramatta	NSW	Julie Owens	4.4
10.	Reid	NSW	John Murphy	2.7
11.	Richmond	NSW	Justine Elliot	7.0
12.	Robertson	NSW	Deb O’Neill	1.0
13.	Chisholm	VIC	Anna Burke	5.8
14.	Corangamite	VIC	Darren Cheeseman	0.3
15.	Deakin	VIC	Mike Symon	0.6
16.	La Trobe	VIC	Laura Smyth	1.7
17.	Blair	QLD	Shayne Neumann	4.2
18.	Capricornia	QLD	Kirsten Livermore (retiring)	3.7
19.	Lilley	QLD	Wayne Swan	3.2
20.	Moreton	QLD	Graham Perrett	1.1
21.	Petrie	QLD	Yvette D’Ath	2.5
22.	Brand	WA	Gary Gray	3.3
23.	Perth	WA	Stephen Smith	5.9
24.	Adelaide	SA	Kate Ellis	7.5
25.	Hindmarsh	SA	Steve Georganas	6.1
26.	Bass	TAS	Geoff Lyons	6.7
27.	Braddon	TAS	Sid Sidebottom	7.5
28.	Lingiari	NT	Warren Snowdon	3.7

ALP SEATS AT SERIOUS RISK (9)

Some of these seats have been marginal and switched parties at various times in recent years, especially when government has changed hands. Whether they are at serious risk or merely at risk is open to debate. Electoral boundaries have altered over time, so historical comparisons are fraught. [Read more…]

Filed Under: 2013 Federal Election, A.L.P., Gillard, Opinion Tagged With: 2013 Federal Election, A.L.P., election predictions

Apr	MAR	Oct
	15
2013	2015	2016

It’s Over: Defeat Looms For The Rudd Government

Alternative Universes And The PNG Solution

Where Are The Seats Rudd Needs To Win?

TASMANIA

VICTORIA

Woof Woof!

2013 Federal Election: How Many Seats Will Labor Lose?

ALP SEATS MOST LIKELY TO BE LOST (28)

ALP SEATS AT SERIOUS RISK (9)

Search AustralianPolitics.com

Connections

Try A Tag

Recent Posts

Gillard Government

Occasional Opinion